YAML Output Format (Scoring + Verdict)

River Review emits a structured YAML block plus a human-readable summary when you pass --output yaml (CLI) or output_format: yaml (GitHub Action). This format targets external CI integrations and BI dashboards.

CLI

npx river run . --output yaml

GitHub Action

- uses: s977043/river-review/runners/github-action@v1.22.0
  with:
    output_format: yaml

Sample output

review:
  phase: midstream
  timestamp: '2026-04-18T00:00:00Z'
  verdict: human-review-recommended
  scores:
    overall: 86
    readability: 100
    extensibility: 100
    performance: 80
    security: 100
    maintainability: 90
  derived: true # scores are heuristic, not AI-generated
  high_risk_reasons:
    - security
  summary: '2 findings: 1 major / 1 minor. Overall score 86/100 (human-review-recommended).'
  findings:
    - severity: major
      category: performance
      file: 'src/Repository/OrderRepository.php'
      line: 128
      title: 'N+1 query in loop'
      detail: 'Eager load relations'
      suggestion: 'Use with()'

A Japanese human-readable summary (result / verdict / breakdown / finding counts) follows the YAML block.

Scoring model

5 axes

axis	Japanese	Area
readability	可読性	Naming, structure, clarity
extensibility	拡張性	Architecture, dependency direction, separation of concerns
performance	パフォーマンス	N+1, loop I/O, query efficiency
security	セキュリティ	Input validation, auth, sensitive data handling
maintainability	保守性	Test quality, pattern conformance

Axis classification

The ruleId prefix of each finding determines the axis. Patterns live in src/lib/scoring/rubric.mjs as AXIS_PATTERNS.

Pattern	axis
rr-*-sec-*, *-security-*, *-auth-*	security
rr-*-perf-*, *-n-plus-one-*, *-query-*	performance
rr-*-arch-*, *-depend-*, *-layer-*	extensibility
rr-*-read-*, *-naming-*, *-complexity-*	readability
rr-*-test-*, *-coverage-*	maintainability
(otherwise)	maintainability (fallback)

Deduction table

Each axis starts at 100 and is deducted per finding by severity.

severity	security	other axes
critical	-50	-30
major	-30	-20
minor	-15	-10
info	-5	-3

overall is the arithmetic mean of the 5 axis scores.

Verdict

verdict	Condition	Meaning
auto-approve	overall ≥90 AND security ≥95 AND critical=0 AND major=0	Recommended for auto-approval. HITL policy still applies; humans make the final merge call.
human-review-recommended	Not the above AND critical=0 AND overall ≥70	Human review recommended.
human-review-required	critical ≥1 OR overall <70	Human review required.

Important caveats

• derived: true flag: The score is a deterministic, heuristic indicator—not an LLM-generated qualitative judgment. Do not use it as the sole merge criterion.
• auto-approve does not override HITL: River Review's policy assumes human review. The auto-approve verdict is an informational signal for automation tools, not a delegation of merge authority.
• Rubric customization: Currently hardcoded in src/lib/scoring/rubric.mjs. Per-project tuning via config/scoring-rubric.json is a future work item.

References

• src/lib/scoring/engine.mjs — scoring implementation
• src/lib/scoring/rubric.mjs — axis patterns and deduction table
• src/lib/output-formatters/yaml.mjs — YAML emitter
• schemas/review-artifact.schema.json — internal schema (v1, compatible with this output)